Once again, Dallas leaves a draft with additional picks in the next year’s draft. No extra first rounder this time, but an extra third and an extra fourth isn’t too shabby. Some quality players come out of those rounds. (For example, Marion Barber III.)
Overall, I would say that Dallas had a solid if not sexy draft. Their second day maneuvering was enough to bring them up to around a B- for the entire draft. Not only did the get a few extra picks, but they picked up another running back (much needed for depth) and another sub-4.40 40 cornerback — never can get too many speedy cover guys. At the very least, that guy is going to get some playing time on special teams.
In fact, if you add the special teams impact into the equation, Dallas may very well have improved that area after letting some key players go in the offseason (Keith Davis and Nate Jones being two stars of our special teams unit last year). Both cornerbacks (Jenkins and Scandrick) should see some time on the special teams squad, the tight end (Bennett) should also be able to help out, and I wouldn’t be surprised to see Felix Jones lining up to return kickoffs — though Jenkins may be able to fill that role too. That is if the Cowboys don’t just put Pacman back there.
Still, two key moves keep me from giving them anything more than a B-. Choosing Felix Jones over Rashard Mendenhall was a mistake. It was a matter of choosing a player that was right for your team over a player that was rated higher on your board — and when you are talking about two players that are at the same position, that’s a dicey game at best.
In the end, it could very well work out nicely for the Cowboys. So long as Barber remains healthy and on the team (remember, he’s still got to sign a contract at some point), the Felix Jones pick may look very nice indeed. And, to be fair, both Mendenhall and Jones had a little gamble to the pick — Mendenhall could be a one hit wonder while Jones might find it harder to run when teams aren’t keying on McFadden in the same backfield.
The second key move is the tight end headscratcher. I get why they picked up Bennett. He looks like he can become one of those guys who can do a great job blocking and still punish people in the passing game. But, after letting Miami have Fasano, it was a little bit of a let down.
But, the nice thing is that grading a draft immediately after it has happened is worth about as much as a used stick of gum. The real grades will come in three years when these players either become budding superstars, solid starters, roster depth, on another team or out of the NFL completely. If Felix Jones can become that Marshall Faulk type player and Bennett is a formidable weapon at tight end, this draft could be elevated to A caliber. (I didn’t add Jenkins being a starter at cornerback — let’s face it, with Newman and Pacman, I’d be happy if Jenkins was the NFL’s best third cornerback.)
There is some disappointment in not drafting a receiver. Not so much that I would grade them down for it — Dallas has a nice crop of receivers right now — but it would still have been a smart move for Dallas to pick up a receiver in the second round.
I know, a lot of people will spill out some stuff about how rookie receivers don’t make an impact and yada yada yada. Guess what? It’s because rookie receivers don’t make much of an impact that made wide receiver a position of need in this years draft. The Cowboys don’t need a receiver heading into 2008, they need one heading into 2009 when Glenn probably won’t be with the team and T.O. will be officially middle aged. Drafting one now would have been thinking ahead.
But, since they don’t have that immediate need now, and they can fullfill that need in free agency next year, I won’t grade them down because of it. And, perhaps — just perhaps — this Stanback kid will make it all academic.